Is each of us capable of practicing philanthropy, regardless of our age or means?

Depends on whom you ask.

For Catherine W. Howard, vice provost of the Division of Community Engagement at Virginia Commonwealth University, the answer is: absolutely.

"I think everyone can be a philanthropist regardless of age or income level," said Howard, a psychology professor. "It is a matter of heart, not wealth. It is also a matter of intention. A true philanthropist believes in the cause to which they are contributing and believes that their contribution can make a difference for that cause."

Not so, said Jon Stuckey, development director of Messiah College, a small Christian, liberal arts school in Pennsylvania.

"Everyone can be a fundraiser; asking people for money is not that hard of a thing to do," he said. "But not everyone can practice philanthropy."

"Philanthropy implies a relationship where you are seeking to help the donor meet his or her charitable goals while benefiting your own institution.

"There are ever-present competing demands, for example - dollar goals that need to be met, visiting with a certain number of donors each year, finding ways to be in contact with busy donors who may not have time to see you in person, and working with the donor to meet their expectations for their giving."

Right there, two very different perspectives and definitions of philanthropy.

Another question to consider when donating: Are you promoting a good cause or promoting yourself? Personal passion or personal reward? Maybe both?

It's a layered issue for individuals as well as corporations, as many motivations exist for giving.

So, what do you think?

Your opinion matters as the sputtering economy has the need for services rising and some charitable contributions declining.

Share your thoughts so we can continue this conversation.

. . .